If there’s one kitchen utensil we use almost every day, it’s the cookie sheet. That’s why you should always invest in utensils that work hard and last long, batch after batch. If you want to make crispy baked bacon, one of our easy pan dishes, or of course, cookies, you’ll need a cookie sheet. If your current cookie sheet is looking warped, scratched or tarnished and producing burnt or unevenly baked treats, it’s time to invest in a new one.
Our Top Picks
So what makes a cookie sheet a cookie sheet?
The big debate: cookie sheet or baking sheet. You may see and use the term (and the products themselves) interchangeably, and you know what? It doesn’t matter. The only actual difference between the two is that cookie sheets have one raised side, while baking sheets have four. You can roast vegetables with ease on either of these sheets, but baking sheets have a slight advantage for cooking meats: the raised sides keep all the juicy flavors inside the sheet. We include both cookie sheets and baking sheets in our top picks.
What are the different sizes of cookie sheets?
We’re glad you asked! While some baking sheets are a little different, the standard sizes are:
A standard size cookie sheet is 26 x 18 inches.
A half sheet pan is 18 x 13 inches.
A cake pan measures 15.5 x 10.5 inches.
A quarter sheet pan measures 9 x 13 inches.
1. Nordic Ware natural aluminum commercial half sheet pan, 2 pack
Any chef or home cook you talk to will recommend this Nordic Ware baking sheet. We appreciate it for its even heating, low price and long life. Need to know more? Check out the 28,000 5-star (!!!) reviews on Amazon. These sheets are also available in a variety of sizes, such as the jelly roll, quarter sheet mold, and full sheet mold.
Buy: Nordic Ware natural aluminum commercial half sheet pan, 2 pack
2. Chicago Metallic Professional Nonstick Baking Sheet
They make Chicago Metallic Professional Nonstick Baking Sheet of heavy carbon steel, which disperses weight and heat evenly no matter what you are cooking. And we can’t forget to mention that this model comes with a 25-year warranty (think of how many batches of cookies that are!).
Buy: Chicago Metallic Professional Nonstick Baking Sheet
3. T-fal AirBake non-stick cookie sheet
Some people prefer to bake with rimless cookie sheets to facilitate air circulation in the oven. If you’ve invested in quality oven mitts, the Micro-Dome technology of the T-fal AirBake Nonstick Cookie Sheet claims to “reduce baking time by up to 15%.”
Buy: T-fal AirBake non-stick cookie sheet
4. TeamFar baking sheet, set of 2
The TeamFar baking sheet is going to fit really well in your kitchen. The stainless steel material is so sturdy and durable that it makes it easy to roast, bake or serve any dish.
Buy: TeamFar baking sheet, set of 2
5. Good Cook Steel Nonstick Baking Sheet, 13 x 9 inches
For a more economical option, look no further than the Good Cook Steel Nonstick Baking Pan. Its scratch-resistant and has a non-stick coating, and you can put it in the dishwasher as soon as you’re done cooking.
Buy: Good Cook Steel Nonstick Baking Sheet, 13 x 9 inches
6. Rachael Ray Nonstick Cookware with Handles
The deep interior and high handles of the Rachael Ray Nonstick Cookware are perfect for roasting meat with vegetables. All the juices will stay in the pan, while the silicone handles make it easy to grab with hot pads.
Buy: Rachael Ray Nonstick Cookware with Handles
7. Nutrichef 3-piece set with silicone handles
Sometimes you’re cooking dinner for one person, sometimes you’re baking cookies for several. It’s nice to have options, which is why the Nutrichef 3-piece set (13.25 x 9.25 inches, 15.25 x 10.25 inches, and 17.25 x 11.5 inches) is handy for the accomplished host.
Buy: Nutrichef 3-piece set with silicone handles
